PokePitchShop LogoPokePitchShop

Columbia, Missouri · Buying & Consignment

We buy graded cards & collections — or sell them for you

Graded star-player cards are the heart of what PokePitchShop sells. If you have slabs or a collection to move, we'll make you a fair offer or consign them to our buyers.

Get an offer

Three ways to sell

Sell outright

Get a straight offer for your graded cards or whole collection. Accept it and you get paid — no waiting for a buyer.

Consign

Want top dollar? We photograph, list, and ship your cards to our buyers, then pay you when they sell. Commission agreed up front — no surprises.

Local pickup

In the Columbia, MO area? We can meet you or pick up larger collections in person.

What we're looking for

  • PSA, BGS, and SGC graded sports cards
  • Star players — Griffey, Ohtani, Judge, Shaq, Randy Johnson, and more
  • Vintage baseball, basketball, and football
  • Full collections, binders, and boxes of raw cards
  • Pokémon and other TCG cards are also considered

Recent sales

  • 1990 Topps Jumbo Pack Glossy Rookies Ken Griffey Jr #11 PSA 10Sold Sep 2026$700
  • 1997 Metal Universe Ken Griffey Jr Blast FurnaceSold Aug 2026$810
  • 1993-94 Topps Finest Shaquille O'Neal Autograph PSA/DNA 10Sold Sep 2026$452
  • 2023 Topps Chrome Ultraviolet All-Stars complete set PSA 10Sold Sep 2025$1,800

How it works

  1. 1

    Send us the details

    Fill out the form below with what you have. Photos help — email them after you submit.

  2. 2

    Get an offer or consignment plan

    We review your cards and reply with a cash offer, a consignment plan, or both.

  3. 3

    Get paid or get listed

    Accept the offer and get paid, or we list your cards and pay you as they sell.

Questions

Do you buy raw (ungraded) cards?
Yes, especially as part of a larger collection. Graded star-player cards are our focus, but tell us what you have.
How does consignment work?
We agree on the commission before anything is listed. We handle photos, listing, and shipping, and pay you after each sale.
Do I have to accept your offer?
No. Every offer is free and no-obligation.
Can I send photos?
Yes — after submitting the form, email photos to sell@pokepitchshop.com with your name in the subject line.
I'm not in Columbia. Can I still sell to you?
Yes — send us the details and we'll work out shipping. Local pickup is an extra option for the Columbia, MO area.
Tell us what you have
No obligation. We usually reply within 24 hours.